Murraymakes

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Tuesday, 9 October 2012

Politics and ponies. Or, a divagation on authenticity and assumptions.

Posted on 04:50 by Unknown

Author’s note: slight warning for length. Sorry about that.

 

There is an awful lot of politics going on. It is conference season, which is like Christmas and Easter for a political anorak like me. Over the pond, the election season is antic with poll reversals, strange veers in position, and a startling amount of statements which are (and I would be thrown out of the Commons for saying this) not true.

Usually, I would be glued to the computer, watching all the speeches, parsing the interviews, ear cocked for the shift in message. It’s not that I am not interested; politics will always fascinate me, it’s like a disease. But I don’t have the time.

There are two secret projects to write, there is my new, enchanting work for HorseBack UK, there are the equines to school and groom and feed and keep generally happy. (There is too, the racing to keep up with; I must not let my William Hill account down under any circumstances.)

This morning, I listened to the Prime Minister in the 8.10 slot on the Today programme. Normally, I would have an awful lot to say about the policy and the positioning and whether there really is a plan for growth.

In fact, the thing that struck me most was a light moment, right at the end, when James Naughtie made a sly little joke about Boris Johnson. For my foreign readers, Johnson is the Mayor of London and easily the most popular politician in Blighty at the moment. In terms of the Tory party, he is the prince across the water, whom disillusioned backbenchers long to draft in as leader, because David Cameron is not right-wing enough, or not anti-Europe enough, or not hard-line enough, or whatever it is that is driving them demented this week.

Perhaps, Naughtie suggested wryly, the PM would like to send Boris abroad somewhere. Cameron burst into laughter. He managed to stutter out some non-committal answer, but he was really tickled.

It was a revealing moment. He went from being a good but standard politician to a vivid human being. Cameron is actually rather good in interview situations; he does not use jargon, he does use humour, and he generally answers the question, as much as any politico does, these days. I can’t work out whether the not answering the question thing has got worse, or whether it has always been the case. I was really struck by it last week, when Ed Miliband was interviewed by Evan Davis in the same slot. He blustered his way through some polite but forensic questioning on the economy, and then he got the softball question at the end. Everyone was impressed with the fact that he memorised his conference speech, Davis said, and that he spoke for so long without notes. How did he do it?

It was a really nice question. It was a perfect opportunity for him to make a little joke about how he stood in front of the looking glass, declaiming, or made his children listen to the thing at breakfast. It also would have been interesting to know, a little glimpse behind the curtain. But Miliband would not answer. Even on that light, charming point, he dodged and fudged. I was surprised, and rather irritated, partly because I rather did want to know, and partly because he missed a huge open goal.

Everyone who knows Ed Miliband says he is very nice, much funnier and easier in private life than in his public persona. This not answering the question does not help in getting that across to the voters. I wonder if politicians are so handled now, so surrounded by advisers, so hamstrung by being on message, or repeating talking points, that they find it almost impossible to be themselves. When the Prime Minister burst into laughter, he was being absolutely himself, and it was like a gale of fresh air. But it happens so rarely. When did you last hear a politician really laugh?

I wonder too if it is slightly the fault of the voters, the old idea that we get the politicians we deserve. Everyone appears to love Boris because he is so funny and outspoken and bumbly and eccentric. Yet most politicians are liable to be punished if they step out of line, say what they really think; it can work, but it can backfire horribly. I suspect most of them think the risks are too great. They stick to this mealy, fudged, on message line, so that no one can have a cudgel to beat them with.

The public and the press say they long for authenticity, but too much authenticity can come back and bite a political operative on the arse. It’s why there is the revealing phenomenon of politicians out of office almost overnight becoming twenty times more interesting and thoughtful and amusing than when they were in power. (John Major and Michael Portillo are the two most shining examples of this.)

The absurd thing, I suddenly realise, is that this was going to be a post about how I was not going to write about politics, and now I have written of it, although not quite in the way I had intended. It’s an aspect of blogging I rather like; there is the galloping off on an unexpected tangent, the liberty to make it up as you go along.

What I really wanted to tell you today was a little story, not about conferences and polls and psephological minutiae, but about my pony. Yes, today is the day when sweet little Myfanwy steps out into the limelight.

It’s a parable really, and I’ll keep it as quick as I can.

She arrived as a rather unexpected loan, to keep Red the Mare company. Compared to my grand duchess, she was a little bit scruffy and little bit furry and a little bit ornery. Because I was working so much with my own horse, I did not pay nearly as much attention to the small Welsh person.

But then I realised that was unfair, and began concentrating on her. With the help of the brilliant Horse Talker, we have taught her to join up, to stand on command, to yield to pressure, to do all the natural horsemanship things, which she loves. We take her for gentle walks and sometimes, for fun, I lead her off Red. With the arrival of Autumn the Filly, we have moved them all into a strict herd routine; we work with them in turn, we groom them and feed them at regular hours, they know what to expect. They are a happy and settled band.

But the pony is the particular revelation. She was tense and uncertain when she first came to her strange new home; there were lines of anxiety over her eyes, and her little jaw was clenched. The more I work with horses the more I see that some of them really, really hate change. You can’t throw them into a new situation and expect them to get on with it, even if they are a tough little mountain breed.

Now that she is bathed in attention, now that she has her own little job to do, the pony has blossomed. Her eyes have softened, she whickers when she sees us, she stands in ecstasy when I scratch her sweet spots. I did not expect to love her as much as Red; I felt mild fondness, but I’m ashamed to say I felt at first she was not in the same league. (Horrid, horrid equine snobbery; I must cast it out.)

Now I am besotted with her. Her coat is soft as velvet from brushing, her ears are pricked, and she has a little dancing swagger about her. Everyone adores her, and she basks in the love. She is an integral part of our herd, and I can’t imagine the field without her.

I think this is a parable because it is all about appearances and assumptions. It’s a sort of frog turning into a prince thing. Just because someone does not look shiny or brilliant or eye-catching does not mean one should sideline them or write them off or make cheap assumptions about them. I had rudely, stupidly, assumed that because Myfanwy was old, and a pony, and a bit roly-poly, she would not learn in the way my sleek, clever Red did.

It was absolute nonsense. When I gave her a chance, she turned out to be a model pupil. And now she is so happy and proud of herself that she grows in beauty every day. She might not be descended from a Derby winner, but she is an absolute champion in all our hearts.

 

Today’s pictures:

The cows, sheep, hills and mountain of Red’s View:

9 Oct 1

9 Oct 2

9 Oct 3

9 Oct 4

9 Oct 5

9 Oct 8

Autumn the Filly is very relaxed in her work:

9 Oct 9

Red was also very chilled out today, looking more like a donkey than a duchess:

9 Oct 14-001

The wibbly lower lip, always a good sign:

9 Oct 15

Inspecting her view:

9 Oct 14

The Pigeon, in three of her different incarnations – sniffing for clues,  yearning for biscuits, and in ball ecstasy:

9 Oct 20

9 Oct 21

9 Oct 23

The heroine of the day goes in the place of honour. See how lovely she looks:

9 Oct 10

9 Oct 11

9 Oct 13

And the dear old hill, very blue and stately today:

9 Oct 24

PS. One of the Dear Readers asked a while ago about the camera I use, and I quite forgot to reply. It is an Olympus PEN 3 series, with a zoom that goes up to 200. I also use Picasa software, free to download, and very good for cropping, putting on colour effects like sepia or black and white, and beefing up contrast if the pictures sometimes come out a bit flat. Very occasionally, the opposite is the case; sometimes the Scottish colours are so wild and surreal that I actually tone them down a bit, because they look too vivid to be true. Oddly like fiction, in that regard.

Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in a good day, an education, assumptions, David Cameron, Evan Davis, James Naughtie, love, Myfanwy the pony, politics, pony, Red the Mare, The Today Programme | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • The brain stutters and stalls. But dear Estimate is back with a bang.
    Work. Other work. Other work. One more piece of vital work. The last of these has the potential to translate into actual game-changing cash ...
  • Sunday. Horses, dogs, family, weather.
    The weather stopped for a moment today; there was even a ray of sunshine. We are surrounded by floods, though; one local town about eight mi...
  • Two sweet things; or, a horse story and a dog story
    Warning for length, horsiness, and dogginess.   The snow came again quite seriously, falling with intent all morning. I defy weather, and I ...
  • I relive the Derby and Red the Mare imitates her more famous cousin. Or, a shaggy horse story for a Sunday afternoon.
    It’s been a wild 24 hours. The Derby was one of the most dramatic I can remember. All the talk was of the mighty Dawn Approach, and my love ...
  • Saturday pictures
    The sweetest and happiest and calmest bit of my day – morning in the field: And random leaves, sheep, playing around with camera setti...
  • Pith. And pictures.
    And back to normal we go, the old routine swinging out on a Monday dawning with skies as black as pitch. Up to HorseBack, back to the comput...
  • All about Dawn Approach
    It is Sussex Day. My heart beats like a big brass drum. Even as I run around, down to ride the mare (our best one yet, leaving me smiling so...
  • Still ill
    Continuing unspeakable. I always think I am rather stoical and brave when I get a bug, and then I get one and am absolutely pathetic. I fant...
  • Out of whack
    I love the internet. I love most of the people on it. I love that its great power is often used for good instead of evil. But sometimes it k...
  • Not exactly a eureka moment.
    As is so often the way, the blog in my head was an absolute stormer. I was going to do a whole thing on manners. There was a piece on them o...

Categories

  • 12.12.12. (5)
  • 2000 Guineas (1)
  • a good day (44)
  • a productive day (1)
  • absurdity (2)
  • ad hominem (1)
  • admiration (1)
  • Afghanistan (2)
  • Aintree (3)
  • Al Kazeem (1)
  • ambition (1)
  • America (2)
  • American politics (2)
  • an education (2)
  • an ordinary day (19)
  • Andy Murray (3)
  • angst (3)
  • animals (2)
  • Anthony Knott (1)
  • AP McCoy (1)
  • arguments (1)
  • art (1)
  • Ascot (10)
  • assumptions (1)
  • authenticity (1)
  • autumn (2)
  • Autumn the Filly (9)
  • bankers (1)
  • Barack Obama (3)
  • Beacon Lady (1)
  • beauty (8)
  • Beckermet (1)
  • Beloveds (1)
  • betting (15)
  • Big Buck's (3)
  • birds (1)
  • birthday (3)
  • Black Caviar (1)
  • blogging (18)
  • blogosphere (3)
  • blossom (1)
  • books (1)
  • bookshops (1)
  • Boris Johnson (1)
  • breeding (1)
  • Brindisi Breeze (2)
  • Britain (6)
  • Britishness (4)
  • Britons (4)
  • brutality (1)
  • butching up (1)
  • calm (1)
  • Camelot (2)
  • cameras (1)
  • Campbell Gillies (1)
  • Captain Conan (1)
  • Carrickbeg (1)
  • carrying on (1)
  • Certify (1)
  • challenges (1)
  • chance (1)
  • Channel Four Racing (4)
  • character flaws (1)
  • Charlotte Dujardin (1)
  • Cheltenham festival (18)
  • children (1)
  • Christian Nock (1)
  • Christmas (8)
  • Clare Balding (2)
  • class (1)
  • cleverness (1)
  • Clive Brittain (1)
  • collective rejoicing (1)
  • computers (1)
  • confidence (1)
  • country life (1)
  • countryside (2)
  • Countrywide Flame (1)
  • courage (1)
  • cousin (1)
  • cricket (1)
  • critics (1)
  • Cumbria (1)
  • cynicism (1)
  • Danny Boyle (1)
  • David Cameron (2)
  • Dawn Approach (5)
  • death (11)
  • Desert Orchid (1)
  • dog pictures (4)
  • dogs (35)
  • domestic life (5)
  • Doris Day (2)
  • drama (2)
  • dreams (1)
  • dressage (3)
  • Dudley the Guide Dog (1)
  • Dynaste (1)
  • each to each (1)
  • Easter (1)
  • Edward the Puppy (2)
  • Emma Hutchison (1)
  • Epsom (1)
  • equal marriage (2)
  • Estimate (3)
  • etiquette (1)
  • Eton (1)
  • Evan Davis (1)
  • exhaustion (1)
  • extremism (1)
  • Facebook (2)
  • failure (1)
  • fairness (1)
  • family (68)
  • fear (3)
  • fillies (1)
  • flat racing (4)
  • Flemenstar (1)
  • flowers (2)
  • food (3)
  • force for good (1)
  • Frankel (13)
  • Frankie Dettori (1)
  • frenzy (1)
  • friendship (9)
  • garden (1)
  • gay marriage (2)
  • George Baker (1)
  • getting on with it (1)
  • glory (4)
  • going home (1)
  • Going south (1)
  • Gold Cup (1)
  • Gold medals (1)
  • good manners (4)
  • good news (4)
  • good things (2)
  • Goodwood (3)
  • grammar (2)
  • grand national (1)
  • gratitude (3)
  • greatness (1)
  • grief (21)
  • groundwork (1)
  • grumpiness (6)
  • guests (2)
  • Guide Dogs for the Blind (1)
  • hair (2)
  • happiness (4)
  • hats (4)
  • heart over head (1)
  • heartbreak (1)
  • Hello Bud (1)
  • help (1)
  • Henry Blofeld (1)
  • Henry Cecil (3)
  • highland games (1)
  • highs and lows (1)
  • hills (1)
  • history (1)
  • holiday (1)
  • home (4)
  • hope (11)
  • hopelessness (1)
  • HorseBack UK (40)
  • horsemanship (34)
  • horses (207)
  • Hot Snap (1)
  • housekeeping (1)
  • hubris (3)
  • human condition (1)
  • human flaws (4)
  • humility (4)
  • Hunt Ball (4)
  • Hurricane Fly (4)
  • idiocy (1)
  • illness (3)
  • Imperial Cavalier (1)
  • Imperial Commander (1)
  • incivility (2)
  • insomnia (1)
  • interesting people (2)
  • internet etiquette (2)
  • James Doyle (1)
  • James Fanshawe (3)
  • James Naughtie (1)
  • Jim Bolger (1)
  • Jock Hutchison (1)
  • John Donne (1)
  • John Gosden (3)
  • John Oaksey (1)
  • Johnny Murtagh (1)
  • journalism (1)
  • Joy (2)
  • jumping (4)
  • Jura the puppy (1)
  • Kauto Star (7)
  • Keith Douglas (1)
  • Kevin Manning (1)
  • kindness (7)
  • Lady Cecil (1)
  • language (3)
  • laughter (1)
  • Laytown Races (1)
  • leadership (2)
  • leaving (2)
  • Leviticus (1)
  • lichen (1)
  • life (78)
  • life goes on (1)
  • life lessons (34)
  • light (2)
  • light and shade (6)
  • lists (2)
  • logistics (1)
  • London (1)
  • Lord Leveson (1)
  • loss (21)
  • Lou Boos and Shoes (1)
  • love (186)
  • loveliness (131)
  • Lucinda Russell (2)
  • luck (3)
  • Mad Moose (1)
  • madness (1)
  • man of letters (1)
  • mares (1)
  • mares and fillies (1)
  • Mark Johnston (1)
  • marriage (1)
  • Martha Payne (1)
  • Mary King (1)
  • Michael Moore (1)
  • Miss Dashwood (1)
  • Miss Whistle (1)
  • missing (1)
  • Mitt Romney (3)
  • Mo Farah (1)
  • Monkerhostin (1)
  • Monty Roberts (1)
  • moods (12)
  • Mothers (1)
  • Mr William Hill (1)
  • musing (1)
  • my father (32)
  • My Godfather (1)
  • my idiot heart (1)
  • my mother (13)
  • My sister (8)
  • my village (3)
  • Myfanwy the pony (23)
  • mysteries of the heart (2)
  • Nathaniel (2)
  • national character (1)
  • national hunt racing (10)
  • natural disaster (1)
  • natural horsemanship (1)
  • nature (1)
  • new life (2)
  • New Year (1)
  • Newmarket (1)
  • Newtown (1)
  • Nicky Henderson (1)
  • Nicola Wilson (1)
  • Nigel Twiston-Davies (1)
  • Nijinsky (3)
  • Nina Carberry (1)
  • No time (1)
  • normality (1)
  • not a blog (1)
  • not answering the question (1)
  • obsessions (1)
  • Oklahoma (1)
  • Olympics (12)
  • Olympus PEN (1)
  • on the train (1)
  • One Good Thing (1)
  • one true thing (1)
  • Opposition Buzz (1)
  • Ortensia (1)
  • otherness (1)
  • Overturn (3)
  • pain and pleasure (1)
  • passion (1)
  • patience (1)
  • Patrick Mullins (2)
  • patriotism (1)
  • Paul Burns (1)
  • Paul Nicholls (2)
  • pedantry (1)
  • perfection (1)
  • perspective (4)
  • Photographs (6)
  • pictures (1)
  • Pigeon (18)
  • Plato (1)
  • poetry (1)
  • politeness (1)
  • politics (12)
  • polo (1)
  • pony (2)
  • possibility (1)
  • prejudice (1)
  • Prussian (1)
  • PTSD (1)
  • Quevega (5)
  • racing (78)
  • rain (1)
  • random thoughts (4)
  • randomness (3)
  • really quite dull (1)
  • Rebecca Curtis (1)
  • recipe (2)
  • Red Letter Day (3)
  • Red the Mare (192)
  • regret (1)
  • remembrance (1)
  • Remembrance Sunday (1)
  • Richard Hughes (1)
  • riding (51)
  • Riposte (1)
  • Ruby Walsh (6)
  • Ruler of the World (1)
  • Ryan Moore (2)
  • sadness (3)
  • Sam Twiston-Davies (2)
  • Sanctuaire (1)
  • saying the thing (1)
  • Scotland (22)
  • Scott Meenagh (1)
  • Seamus Heaney (1)
  • Secret Gesture (1)
  • Secretary of State for Scotland (1)
  • setbacks (1)
  • shame (2)
  • sheep (5)
  • sheer beauty (25)
  • Shirley Teasdale (4)
  • shopping (1)
  • show-jumping (1)
  • Simonsig (1)
  • singing (1)
  • Sir Graham Wade (1)
  • Sir Henry Cecil (5)
  • Sir Prancealot (1)
  • Sky Lantern (2)
  • slight oddness (1)
  • small life lessons (1)
  • small things (2)
  • snow (12)
  • snow dogs (3)
  • Snow Fairy (1)
  • social life (2)
  • social media (2)
  • Society Rock (1)
  • solipsism (1)
  • Somerset (1)
  • sorrow (8)
  • soup (2)
  • special green soup (1)
  • spring (5)
  • Sprinter Sacre (6)
  • Stanley the Lurcher (36)
  • sunshine (2)
  • support your local business (1)
  • swallows (2)
  • sweetness (7)
  • Syria (2)
  • tangents (1)
  • Teaforthree (2)
  • Team GB (6)
  • tears (1)
  • Tebay (2)
  • terrorism (1)
  • Test Match Special (1)
  • The Agent (1)
  • The Arkle (1)
  • The Ashes (1)
  • the bad news (1)
  • The Barefoot Trimmer (2)
  • The Beloved Cousin (5)
  • The blog (2)
  • the blogosphere (1)
  • The Borders (1)
  • The British (1)
  • The Brother-in-Law (1)
  • The Cousins (23)
  • The Cross People (1)
  • The Dalai Lama (1)
  • The Dear Readers (7)
  • The Derby (3)
  • The Duchess (13)
  • The Ducking Stool (1)
  • the economy (1)
  • The Expatriate (2)
  • The Farmer (2)
  • The Farrier (1)
  • The glen (1)
  • the good old men (1)
  • The Grand National (1)
  • the great mares (1)
  • The Hebrides (2)
  • The herd (15)
  • The Horse Talker (13)
  • The HorseBack foal (1)
  • the human condition (4)
  • the human heart (11)
  • the internet (6)
  • The Jubilee (1)
  • The Lockinge (1)
  • The Love Song of J Alfred Prufrock (1)
  • The Man in the Hat (1)
  • The military (1)
  • The National Gallery (1)
  • the new regime (1)
  • the news (3)
  • The Oaks (1)
  • The Old Fella (3)
  • the old people (1)
  • The Older Brother (2)
  • The Older Niece (1)
  • the Olympics (1)
  • The Pankhursts (1)
  • the perspective police (3)
  • The Pigeon (56)
  • The Playwright (3)
  • The Point (1)
  • The Pony Whisperer (2)
  • the press (1)
  • The Queen (7)
  • the real world (1)
  • The Remarkable Trainer (1)
  • The royal family (1)
  • The Royal Meeting (5)
  • the small things (13)
  • The Smallest Cousin (1)
  • The South (1)
  • The Stepfather (1)
  • The Tarland Show (1)
  • the thoroughbred (1)
  • The Today Programme (1)
  • The vet (2)
  • the wisdom of horses (1)
  • The World Traveller (4)
  • The Young Gentleman (1)
  • The Young People (4)
  • The Younger Brother (3)
  • The Younger Niece (1)
  • theories (4)
  • therapy (1)
  • Things I Like (1)
  • things of beauty (1)
  • thinking (1)
  • thoughts (2)
  • three day event (2)
  • time (6)
  • Tina Cook (1)
  • Tom Daley (1)
  • Tom Queally (3)
  • Topham (1)
  • Toronado (2)
  • tragedy (1)
  • training (1)
  • travelling (1)
  • trees (5)
  • tribes (1)
  • triumph and tragedy (1)
  • trust (2)
  • TS Eliot (1)
  • Twitter (8)
  • utility (1)
  • Valentine's Day (1)
  • vanity (1)
  • village life (1)
  • walk (1)
  • weather (23)
  • weddings (1)
  • whim (1)
  • William Buick (2)
  • William Fox-Pitt (1)
  • Willy Twiston-Davies (2)
  • winter quarters (1)
  • wisdom (1)
  • women (2)
  • words (5)
  • words matter (4)
  • work (10)
  • worries (1)
  • writing (23)
  • writing workshop (1)
  • Writing Workshop 2013 (3)
  • York (1)
  • zebras (1)

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (206)
    • ►  September (5)
    • ►  August (20)
    • ►  July (24)
    • ►  June (26)
    • ►  May (22)
    • ►  April (26)
    • ►  March (26)
    • ►  February (27)
    • ►  January (30)
  • ▼  2012 (294)
    • ►  December (34)
    • ►  November (30)
    • ▼  October (28)
      • Running out of words
      • HorseBack, dogs, love, perspective, and a remarkab...
      • The saddest day
      • Sunday pictures
      • A wedding
      • Mostly pictures
      • What a difference a day makes. Or, fantasy and rea...
      • A day of two halves; or, the perspective police re...
      • In which I have absolutely no idea what I am talki...
      • Farewell, Frankel; in which I say goodbye to a tru...
      • THE MIGHTY FRANKEL
      • The final Frankel Day
      • Random Friday
      • Angst; or, sometimes I really think I should not b...
      • Frankel versus the fence. The fence wins.
      • A day at HorseBack UK
      • Back from the Borders; or, a little hymn of praise...
      • Weekend off
      • A good mood
      • Of mortality and dogs and perspective police
      • Politics and ponies. Or, a divagation on authentic...
      • Could everyone PLEASE stop shouting?
      • Saturday in brief
      • A few bullet holes
      • Thursday Sketch
      • Random Wednesday
      • The klaxon sounds:Absolutely massive life lesson a...
      • Bit of a non-blog blog
    • ►  September (28)
    • ►  August (22)
    • ►  July (31)
    • ►  June (25)
    • ►  May (26)
    • ►  April (30)
    • ►  March (29)
    • ►  February (11)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile